Summary

Top 8 papers analyzed

Legal cases often involve complex questions of law and fact that require human judgment, intuition and experience to resolve. While large language models show promise for automating some limited legal tasks, they currently lack the sophisticated reasoning skills needed to fully understand and decide legal disputes. Some recent papers have explored using LLMs to predict case outcomes or detect legal concepts and relations in text. For example, a 2019 paper developed a neural network with BiGRU encoders to encode facts and laws, combined with attention and hidden layers to predict case outcomes. They achieved 63% accuracy on a set of Indian Supreme Court cases. Another paper in 2020 proposed a hierarchical multi-task framework to jointly extract legal concepts, detect relations between sentences, and predict entailment between sentences. However, legal judgment involves subtle, complex aspects like assessing witness credibility, balancing ambiguous or conflicting laws, and considering social justice implications. LLMs today have narrow, superficial understandings of language and the world, and lack the general knowledge, logical reasoning, and social-emotional skills required to replicate human legal reasoning. They cannot match attorneys’ years of formal education and professional experience. While natural language processing will likely transform some areas of legal practice over time, human lawyers and judges will remain essential to the fair administration of justice. Their role may shift to overseeing AI systems and ensuring they are applied appropriately, but human judgment and wisdom will continue to be vital in resolving complex, consequential legal matters. Overall, we are still quite far from having AI systems with the multifaceted, nuanced reasoning abilities needed to fully take over central functions of legal professionals. But as models become more advanced, partnerships between human lawyers and AI may help improve efficiency, reduce costs, and increase access to legal services. The legal profession will need to thoughtfully incorporate new technologies to stay relevant in the 21st century while upholding principles of ethics, fairness and justice.

The impact of ChatGPT on the legal profession, challenges, and recommendations for lawyers to adapt to AI are discussed. While tasks may change, the role of lawyers will continue in a new form, emphasizing the need for adaptation to new technologies.

Published By:

N Noonan - Available at SSRN 4406907, 2023 - papers.ssrn.com

Cited By:

0

"ChatGPT" is a large language model released by OpenAI for users to provide feedback on its user-centered approach, revolutionizing scientific literature production. The model differs from its predecessors in its paradigm shift towards a new methodology for training.

Published By:

L De Angelis, F Baglivo, G Arzilli, GP Privitera… - Frontiers in Public …, 2023 - frontiersin.org

Cited By:

0

Comprehensive survey of ChatGPT-related research, focusing on GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 large language models. Analyzing innovations that enhance adaptability and performance, revealing growing interest in natural language processing applications.

Published By:

Y Liu, T Han, S Ma, J Zhang, Y Yang, J Tian, H He, A Li… - Meta-Radiology, 2023 - Elsevier

Cited By:

0

UniLMv2: pseudo-masked language models for unified language model pre-training. Unified language model pre-training for natural language understanding and generation.

Published By:

K Sun, X Luo, MY Luo - International Conference on Knowledge Science …, 2022 - Springer

Cited By:

0

Recently, AI techniques have been used to analyze legal texts.A primary task is detecting relations between sentences, modeled as classification where a classifier decides if one entails the other.

Published By:

E Mumcuoğlu, CE Öztürk, HM Ozaktas, A Koç - Information Processing & …, 2021 - Elsevier

Cited By:

0

A two-stage model generates language and adapts word frequencies.Power-law distributions and reduced errors in learning emerge by manipulating the model.

Published By:

S Goldwater, TL Griffiths, M Johnson - Journal of Machine Learning …, 2011 - jmlr.org

Cited By:

0

Large language models like GPT could affect many jobs.Around 19% of US workers have over half of tasks highly exposed,increasing with wages but not employment.

Published By:

T Eloundou, S Manning, P Mishkin, D Rock - arXiv preprint arXiv …, 2023 - arxiv.org

Cited By:

0

LLMs struggles in solving complex scientific problems; a benchmark indicates the best LLM achieves only 43.22% in math,chemistry and physics problems, lacking various scientific skills.Strategies improve certain skills but weaken others.

Published By:

X Wang, Z Hu, P Lu, Y Zhu, J Zhang… - arXiv preprint arXiv …, 2023 - arxiv.org

Cited By:

0